Tarasoff v. Regents of University of California Case Brief
LSD Deep Dive ∘ Audio Lesson
A two-host discussion of this case - listen on your commute or between classes
tl;dr: Tatiana’s parents alleged that therapists recognized Poddar’s threat to kill her but failed to warn of the danger. The court allowed amendment of claims against the therapists and their employer, while affirming dismissal of the police defendants and recognizing immunity for confinement decisions.
Legal Significance: The decision recognizes a therapist’s duty to use reasonable care to protect foreseeable victims when professional standards require recognition of a patient’s serious danger of violence. It distinguishes that protective duty from immunized confinement decisions and limits confidentiality where disclosure is essential to avert danger.
Case Facts & Court Holding
Key Facts & Case Background
Poddar killed Tatiana Tarasoff on October 27, 1969. Her parents alleged that, while receiving outpatient therapy at Cowell Memorial Hospital, Poddar told Moore he intended to kill an unnamed girl readily identifiable as Tatiana. According to the complaints, Moore, with Gold’s and Yandell’s concurrence, decided Poddar should be committed for observation and requested campus police assistance. Officers detained Poddar but released him after finding him rational and obtaining his promise to stay away from Tatiana. Plaintiffs alleged that Powelson then countermanded efforts to obtain confinement and directed destruction of Moore’s letter and treatment notes. They alleged that defendants failed to warn them of the danger to their daughter.
The parents filed separate, substantially identical complaints against the therapists, police defendants, and the Regents as employer, asserting failures to detain and warn, abandonment, and breach of duty to the patient and public. They also sought punitive damages against Powelson. The superior court sustained demurrers to the second amended complaints without leave to amend. Plaintiffs appealed.
Court Holding & Legal Precedent
Issue: Could Tatiana’s parents amend their complaints to state claims against the therapists and their employer for negligent failure to protect her from Poddar, despite asserted limits on duty, confidentiality requirements, and governmental immunity, and did dismissal remain proper for the police defendants?
The court reversed the judgment for the therapists and the Regents and remanded, permitting amendment to allege negligent failure to protect Tatiana through warnings to her or others likely to notify her. The alleged therapeutic relationships could support a protective duty, and neither discretionary immunity nor the confidentiality provisions invoked barred that warning claim on these pleadings. Confinement-based claims remained barred by immunity, and punitive damages were unavailable in the wrongful death action. The court affirmed the judgment for the police defendants because plaintiffs supplied no basis for a duty to warn and the officers were immune from liability for releasing Poddar.
IRAC Legal Analysis
Legal Issue
Could Tatiana’s parents amend their complaints to state claims against the therapists and their employer for negligent failure to protect her from Poddar, despite asserted limits on duty, confidentiality requirements, and governmental immunity, and did dismissal remain proper for the police defendants?
Conclusion
The case establishes a context-dependent duty of reasonable protection arising from the therapist-patient relationship when serious violence is recognized or professionally should be recognized. Its reach remains qualified by professional standards, applicable governmental immunities, and the absence of any adjudication that these defendants were negligent.
Legal Rule
When a therapist determines, or under professional standards should determine, that a patient presents a serious danger of violence to another, the therapist must exercise reasonable care to protect the foreseeable victim. Appropriate measures depend on the circumstances and may include warnings, police notification, or other reasonably necessary steps. The therapist-patient relationship supplies the special relationship contemplated by Restatement Second of Torts section 315. Professional care is measured by the standard described in Bardessono v. Michels (1970) 3 Cal.3d 780, 788, and Quintal v. Laurel Grove Hospital (1964) 62 Cal.2d 154, 159-160. Under Johnson v. State of California (1968) 69 Cal.2d 782, Government Code section 820.2 protects basic policy decisions, not the failure to warn at issue here. Government Code section 856 immunizes determinations involved in confinement; Welfare and Institutions Code section 5154 protects the police defendants from liability for releasing Poddar.
Legal Analysis
The court applied the policy considerations identified in Rowland v. Christian (1968) 69 Cal.2d 108, emphasizing foreseeability while retaining the special-relationship requirement for affirmative protection against another’s conduct. The therapist-patient relationship could support duties to threatened third persons even without a therapeutic relationship with the victim. The court expressly left undecided whether foreseeability alone could establish such a duty.
Defendants’ concerns about unreliable predictions did not eliminate the duty. The court required ordinary professional competence, not perfect prediction; hindsight alone could not establish negligence. Moreover, the complaints alleged actual recognition of Poddar’s dangerousness. Unlike People v. Burnick (1975) 14 Cal.3d 306, the case concerned protective measures that need not deprive the patient of liberty.
Confidentiality yielded only where disclosure was necessary to avert danger, with privacy preserved as far as compatible with protection. Evidence Code section 1024 supported this balance but did not itself create the duty. The pleadings did not establish treatment governed by the Lanterman-Petris-Short Act’s confidentiality provisions, and defendants conceded the absence of county designation authorizing Moore to initiate section 5150 proceedings.
Applying Johnson, the court found the alleged failure to warn outside basic policymaking protected by section 820.2. Section 856 nevertheless immunized decisions concerning confinement, including alleged acquiescence in Powelson’s countermand. The court did not decide whether Moore otherwise owed a duty to overcome his superior’s opposition. Police liability failed independently because no sufficient special relationship or alternative factual basis for a warning duty was pleaded. Amendment permitted litigation of negligence and causation; it did not establish liability.
Separate opinions
Mosk, concurring and dissenting: Mosk agreed that a cause of action could be stated because the complaints alleged actual prediction of violence. He rejected liability based on what therapists should have predicted under professional standards, emphasizing predictive unreliability. He regarded the adequacy of police notification as a factual question available in defense.
Clark, dissenting: Clark argued that the Lanterman-Petris-Short Act required confidentiality and foreclosed the warning duty. Independently, he maintained that compelled disclosure would undermine treatment, increase violence, and encourage unnecessary commitment. He would affirm the judgment. McComb concurred in his opinion.
The Opinions
Summary
- A psychotherapist has a duty to protect a third party when their patient presents a serious, foreseeable danger of violence to that person.
- The duty arises from the “special relationship” between therapist and patient, which creates an exception to the general rule of no duty to control others.
- The court famously balanced policy considerations, stating: “The protective privilege ends where the public peril begins.”
Full text
Complete unedited opinion text as published by the court
Opinion
On October 27, 1969, Prosenjit Poddar killed Tatiana Tarasoff.
Concluding that these facts set forth causes of action against neither therapists and policemen involved, nor against the Regents of the University of California as their employer, the superior court sustained defendants’ demurrers to plaintiffs’ second amended complaints without leave to amend.
We shall explain that defendant therapists cannot escape liability merely because Tatiana herself was npt their patient. (1) When a therapist determines, or pursuant to the standards of his profession should determine, that his patient presents a serious danger of violence to another, he incurs an obligation to use reasonable care to protect the intended victim against such danger. The discharge of this duty may require the therapist to take one or more of various steps, depending upon the nature of the case. Thus it may call for him to warn the intended victim or others likely to apprise the victim of the danger, to notify the police, or to take whatever other steps are reasonably necessary under the circumstances.
In the case at bar, plaintiffs admit that defendant therapists notified the police, but argue on appeal that the therapists failed to exercise reasonable care to protect Tatiana in that they did not confine Poddar and did not warn Tatiana or others likely to apprise her of the danger. Defendant therapists, however, are public employees. Consequently, to the extent that plaintiffs seek to predicate liability upon the therapists’ failure to bring about Poddar’s confinement, the therapists can claim immunity under Government Code section 856. No specific statutory provision, however, shields them from liability based upon failure to warn Tatiana or others likely to apprise her of the danger, and Government Code section 820.2 does not protect such failure as an exercise of discretion.
Plaintiffs therefore can amend their complaints to allege that, regardless of the therapists’ unsuccessful attempt to confine Poddar, since they knew that Poddar was at large and dangerous, their failure to warn Tatiana or others likely to apprise her of the danger constituted a breach of the therapists’ duty to exercise reasonable care to protect Tatiana.
Plaintiffs, however, plead no relationship between Poddar and the police defendants which would impose upon them any duty to Tatiana, and plaintiffs suggest no other basis for such a duty. Plaintiffs have,
1. Plaintiffs’complaints
Plaintiffs, Tatiana’s mother and father, filed separate but virtually identical second amended complaints. The issue before us on this appeal is whether those complaints now state, or can be amended to state, causes of action against defendants. We therefore begin by setting forth the pertinent allegations of the complaints.
Plaintiffs’ first cause of action, entitled “Failure to Detain a Dangerous Patient,” alleges that on August 20, 1969, Poddar was a voluntary outpatient receiving therapy at Cowell Memorial Hospital. Poddar informed Moore, his therapist, that he was going to kill an unnamed girl, readily identifiable as Tatiana, when she returned home from spending the summer in Brazil. Moore, with the concurrence of Dr. Gold, who had initially examined Poddar, and Dr. Yandell, assistant to the director of the department of psychiatry, decided that Poddar should be committed for observation in a mental hospital. Moore orally notified Officers Atkinson and Teel of the campus police that he would request commitment. He then sent a letter to Police Chief William Beall requesting the assistance of the police department in securing Poddar’s confinement.
Officers Atkinson, Brownrigg, and Halleran took Poddar into custody, but, satisfied that Poddar was rational, released him on his promise to stay away from Tatiana. Powelson, director of the department of psychiatry at Cowell Memorial Hospital, then asked the police to return Moore’s letter, directed that all copies of the letter and notes that Moore had taken as therapist be destroyed, and “ordered no action to place Prosenjit Poddar in 72-hour treatment and evaluation facility.”
Plaintiffs’ third cause of action, entitled “Abandonment of a Dangerous Patient,” seeks $10,000 punitive damages against defendant Powelson. Incorporating the crucial allegations of the first cause of action, plaintiffs charge that Powelson “did the things herein alleged with intent to abandon a dangerous patient, and said acts were done maliciously and oppressively.”
Plaintiffs’ fourth cause of action, for “Breach of Primary Duty to Patient and the Public,” states essentially the same allegations as the first cause of action, but seeks to characterize defendants’ conduct as a breach of duty to safeguard their patient and the public. Since such conclusory labels add nothing to the factual allegations of the complaint, the first and fourth causes of action are legally indistinguishable.
As we explain in part 4 of this opinion, plaintiffs’ first and fourth causes of action, which seek to predicate liability upon the defendants’ failure to bring about Poddar’s confinement, are barred by governmental immunity. Plaintiffs’ third cause of action succumbs to the decisions precluding exemplary damages in a wrongful death action. (See part 6 of this opinion.) We direct our attention, therefore, to the issue of whether plaintiffs’ second cause of action can be amended to state a basis for recovery.
2. Plaintiffs can state a cause of action against defendant therapists for negligent failure to protect Tatiana.
The second cause of action can be amended to allege that Tatiana’s death proximately resulted from defendants’ negligent failure to warn Tatiana or others likely to apprise her of her danger. Plaintiffs contend that as amended, such allegations of negligence and proximate causation, with resulting damages, establish a cause of action. Defendants, however, contend that in the circumstances of the present case they owed no duty of care to Tatiana or her parents and that, in the absence of such
In analyzing this issue, we bear in mind that legal duties are not discoverable facts of nature, but merely conclusoiy expressions that, in cases of a particular type, liability should be imposed for damage done. As stated in Dillon v. Legg (1968) 68 Cal.2d 728, 734 [69 Cal.Rptr. 72, 441 P.2d 912, 29 A.L.R.3d 1316]: “The assertion that liability must ... be denied because defendant bears no ‘duty’ to plaintiff ‘begs the essential question—whether the plaintiff’s interests are entitled to legal protection against the defendant’s conduct... . [Duty] is not sacrosanct in itself, but only an expression of the sum total of those considerations of policy which lead the law to say that the particular plaintiff is entitled to protection.’ (Prosser, Law of Torts [3d ed. 1964] at pp. 332-333.)”
In the landmark case of Rowland v. Christian (1968) 69 Cal.2d 108 [70 Cal.Rptr. 97, 443 P.2d 561, 32 A.L.R.3d 496], Justice Peters recognized that liability should be imposed “for injury occasioned to another by his want of ordinary care or skill” as expressed in section 1714 of the Civil Code. Thus, Justice Peters, quoting from Heaven v. Pender (1883) 11 Q.B.D, 503, 509 stated: “ ‘whenever one person is by circumstances placed in such a position with regard to another . .. that if he did not use ordinary care and skill in his own conduct... he would cause danger of injury to the person or property of the other, a duty arises to use ordinary care and skill to avoid such danger.’ ”
We depart from “this fundamental principle” only upon the “balancing of a number of considerations”; major ones “are the foreseeability of harm to the plaintiff, the degree of certainty that the plaintiff suffered injury, the closeness of the connection between the defendant’s conduct and the injury suffered, the moral blame attached to the defendant’s conduct, the policy of preventing future harm, the extent of the burden to the defendant and consequences to the community of imposing a duty to exercise care with resulting liability for breach, and the availability, cost and prevalence of insurance for the risk involved.”
The most important of these considerations in establishing duty is foreseeability. As a general principle, a “defendant owes a duty of
Although, as we have stated above, under the common law, as a general rule, one person owed no duty to control the conduct of another
Although the California decisions that recognize this duty have involved cases in which the defendant stood in a special relationship both to the victim and to the person whose conduct created the danger,
Since it involved a dangerous mental patient, the decision in Merchants Nat. Bank & Trust Co. of Fargo v. United States (D.N.D. 1967) 272 F.Supp. 409 comes closer to the issue. The Veterans Administration arranged for the patient to work on a local farm, but did not inform the farmer of the man’s background. The farmer consequently permitted the patient to come and go freely during nonworking hours; the patient borrowed a car, drove to his wife’s residence and killed her. Notwithstanding the lack of any “special relationship” between the Veterans Administration and the wife, the court found the Veterans Administration liable for the wrongful death of the wife.
In their summary of the relevant rulings Fleming and Maximov conclude that the “case law should dispel any notion that to impose on the therapists a duty to take precautions for the safety of persons threatened by a patient, where due care so requires, is in any way opposed to contemporary ground rules on the duty relationship. On the contrary, there now seems to be sufficient authority to support the conclusion that by entering into a doctor-patient relationship the therapist becomes sufficiently involved to assume some responsibility for the safety, not only of the patient himself, but also of any third person whom the doctor knows to be threatened by the patient.” (Fleming & Maximov, The Patient or His Victim: The Therapist’s Dilemma (1974) 62 Cal.L. Rev. 1025, 1030.)
Defendants contend, however, that imposition of a duty to exercise reasonable care to protect third persons is unworkable because therapists cannot accurately predict whether or not a patient will resort to violence. In support of this argument amicus representing the American Psychiatric Association and other professional societies cites numerous articles which indicate that therapists, in the present state of the art, are unable reliably to predict violent acts; their forecasts, amicus claims, tend consistently to overpredict violence, and indeed are more often wrong
The role of the psychiatrist, who is indeed a practitioner of medicine, and that of the psychologist who performs an allied function, are like that of the physician who must conform to the standards of the profession and who must often make diagnoses and predictions based upon such evaluations. Thus the judgment of the therapist in diagnosing emotional disorders and in predicting whether a patient presents a serious danger of violence is comparable to the judgment which doctors and professionals must regularly render under accepted rules of responsibility.
We recognize the difficulty that a therapist encounters in attempting to forecast whether a patient presents a serious danger of violence. Obviously, we do not require that the therapist, in making that determination, render a perfect performance; the therapist need only exercise “that reasonable degree of skill, knowledge, and care ordinarily possessed and exercised by members of [that professional specialty] under similar circumstances.” (Bardessono v. Michels (1970) 3 Cal.3d 780, 788 [91 Cal.Rptr. 760, 478 P.2d 480, 45 A.L.R.3d 717]; Quintal v. Laurel Grove Hospital (1964) 62 Cal.2d 154, 159-160 [41 Cal.Rptr. 577, 397 P.2d 161]; see 4 Witkin, Summary of Cal. Law (8th ed. 1974) Torts, § 514 and cases cited.) Within the broad range of reasonable practice and treatment in which professional opinion and judgment may differ, the therapist is free to exercise his or her own best judgment without liability; proof, aided by hindsight, that he or she judged wrongly is insufficient to establish negligence.
In the instant case, however, the pleadings do not raise any question as to failure of defendant therapists to predict that Poddar presented a serious danger of violence. On the contrary, the present complaints allege that defendant therapists did in fact predict that Poddar would kill, but were negligent in failing to warn.
Contrary to the assertion of amicus, this conclusion is not inconsistent with our recent decision in People v. Burnick, supra, 14 Cal.3d 306. Taking note of the uncertain character of therapeutic prediction, we held in Burnick that a person cannot be committed as a mentally disordered sex offender unless found to be such by proof beyond a reasonable doubt. (14 Cal.3d at p. 328.) The issue in the present context, however, is not whether the patient should be incarcerated, but whether the therapist should take any steps at all to protect the threatened victim; some of the alternatives open to the therapist, such as warning the victim, will not result in the drastic consequences of depriving the patient of his liberty. Weighing the uncertain and conjectural character of the alleged damage done the patient by such a warning against the peril to the victim’s life, we conclude that professional inaccuracy in predicting violence cannot negate the therapist’s duty to protect the threatened victim.
Defendants further argue that free and open communication is essential to psychotherapy (see In re Lifschutz (1970) 2 Cal.3d 415, 431-434 [85 Cal.Rptr. 829, 467 P.2d 557, 44 A.L.R.3d 1]); that “Unless a patient... is assured that... information [revealed by him] can and will be held in utmost confidence, he will be reluctant to make the full disclosure upon which-diagnosis and treatment... depends.” (Sen. Com. on Judiciary, comment on Evid. Code, § 1014.) The giving of a warning, defendants contend, constitutes a breach of trust which entails the revelation of confidential communications.
We recognize the public interest in supporting effective treatment of mental illness and in protecting the rights of patients to privacy (see In re Lifschutz, supra, 2 Cal.3d at p. 432), and the consequent public importance of safeguarding the confidential character of psychotherapeutic communication. Against this interest, however, we must weigh the public interest in safety from violent assault. The Legislature has undertaken the difficult task of balancing the countervailing concerns. In Evidence Code section 1014, it established a broad rule of privilege to protect confidential communications between patient and psychothera
We realize that the open and confidential character of psychotherapeutic dialogue encourages patients to express threats of violence, few of which are ever executed. Certainly a therapist should not be encouraged routinely to reveal such threats; such disclosures could seriously disrupt the patient’s relationship with his therapist and with the persons threatened. To the contrary, the therapist’s obligations to his patient require that he not disclose a confidence unless such disclosure is necessary to avert danger to others, and even then that he do so discreetly, and in a fashion that would preserve the privacy of his patient to the fullest extent compatible with the prevention of the threatened danger. (See Fleming & Maximov, The Patient or His Victim: The Therapist’s Dilemma (1974) 62 Cal.L.Rev. 1025, 1065-1066.)
The revelation of a communication under the above- circumstances is not a breach of trust or a violation of professional ethics; as stated in the Principles of Medical Ethics of the American Medical Association (1957), section 9: “A physician may not reveal the confidence entrusted to him in the course of medical attendance .. . unless he is required to do so by law or unless it becomes necessary in order to protect the welfare of
Our current crowded and computerized society compels the interdependence of its members. In this risk-infested society we can hardly tolerate the further exposure to danger that would result from a concealed knowledge of the therapist that his patient was lethal. If the exercise of reasonable care to protect the threatened victim requires the therapist to warn the endangered party or those who can reasonably be expected to notify him, we see no sufficient societal interest that would protect and justify concealment. The containment of such risks lies in the public interest. For the foregoing reasons, we find that plaintiffs’ complaints can be amended to state a cause of action against defendants Moore, Powelson, Gold, and Yandell and against the Regents as their employer, for breach of a duty to exercise reasonable care to protect Tatiana.
Finally, we reject the contention of the dissent that the provisions of the Lanterman-Petris-Short Act which govern the release of confidential information (Welf. & Inst. Code, §§ 5328-5328.9) prevented defendant therapists from warning Tatiana. The dissent’s contention rests on the assertion that Dr. Moore’s letter to the campus police constituted an “application in writing” within the meaning of Welfare and Institutions Code section 5150, and thus initiates proceedings under the Lanterman-Petris-Short Act. A closer look at the terms of section 5150, however, will demonstrate that it is inapplicable to the present case.
Section 5150 refers to a written application only by a professional person who is “a member of the attending staff ... of an evaluation
Furthermore, the provisions of the Lanterman-Petris-Short Act defining a therapist’s duty to withhold confidential information are expressly limited to “information and records obtained in the course of providing services under Division 5 (commencing with section 5000), Division 6 (commencing with section 6000), or Division 7 (commencing with section 7000)” of the Welfare arid Institutions Code (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5328). (Italics added.) Divisions 5, 6 and 7 describe a variety of programs for treatment of the mentally ill or retarded.
Neither can we adopt the dissent’s suggestion that we import wholesale the detailed provisions of the Lanterman-Petris-Short Act regulating the disclosure of confidential information and apply them to disclosure of information not governed by the act. Since the Legislature did not extend the act to control all disclosures of confidential matter by a therapist, we must infer that the Legislature did not relieve the courts of their obligation to define by reference to the principles of the common law the obligation of the therapist in those situations not governed by the act.
3. Defendant therapists are not immune from liability for failure to
warn.
We address the issue of whether defendant therapists are protected by governmental immunity for having failed to warn Tatiana or those who reasonably could have been expected to notify her of her peril. We postulate our analysis on section 820.2 of the Government Code.
We also observed that if courts did not respect this statutory immunity, they would find themselves “in the unseemly position of determining the propriety of decisions expressly entrusted to a coordinate branch of government.” (Johnson v. State of California, supra, at p. 793.) It therefore is necessary, we concluded, to “isolate those areas of quasi-legislative policy-making which are sufficiently sensitive to justify a blanket rule that courts will not entertain a tort action alleging that careless conduct contributed to the governmental decision.” (Johnson v. State of California, supra, at p. 794.) After careful analysis we rejected, in Johnson, other rationales commonly advanced to support governmental immunity
Relying on Johnson, we conclude that defendant therapists in the present case are not immune from liability for their failure to warn of Tatiana’s peril. Johnson held that a parole officer’s determination whether to warn an adult couple that their prospective foster child had a background of violence “presented] no . . . reasons for immunity” (Johnson v. State of California, supra, at p. 795), was “at the lowest,
We also noted in Johnson that federal courts have consistently categorized failures to warn of latent dangers as falling outside the scope of discretionary omissions immunized by the Federal Tort Claims Act.
We conclude, therefore, that the therapist defendants’ failure to warn Tatiana or those who reasonably could have been expected to notify her of her peril does not fall within the absolute protection afforded by section 820.2 of the Government Code. We emphasize that our conclu
4. Defendant therapists are immune from liability for failing to
confine Poddar.
We sustain defendant therapists’ contention that Government Code section 856 insulates them from liability under plaintiffs’ first and fourth causes of action for failing to confine Poddar. Section 856 affords public entities and their employees absolute protection from liability for “any injury resulting from determining in accordance with any applicable enactment.. . whether to confine a person for mental illness.” Since this section refers to a determination to confine “in accordance with any applicable enactment,” plaintiffs suggest that the immunity is limited to persons designated under Welfare and Institutions Code section 5150 as authorized finally to adjudicate a patient’s confinement. Defendant therapists, plaintiffs point out, are not among the persons designated under section 5150.
The language and legislative history of section 856, however, suggest a far broader immunity. In 1963, when section 856 was enacted, the Legislature had not established the statutoiy structure of the Lanterman-Petris-Short Act. Former Welfare and Institutions Code section 5050.3 (renumbered as Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5880; repealed July 1, 1969) which resembled present section 5150, authorized emergency detention at the behest only of peace officers, health officers, county physicians, or assistant county physicians; former section 5047 (renumbered as Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5551; repealed July 1, 1969), however, authorized a petition seeking commitment by any person, including the “physician attending the patient.” The Legislature did not refer in section 856 only to those persons authorized to institute emergency proceedings under section 5050.3; it broadly extended immunity to all employees who acted in accord with “any applicable enactment,” thus granting immunity not only to persons who are empowered to confine, but also to those authorized to request or recommend confinement.
Turning first to Dr. Powelson’s status with respect to section 856, we observe that the actions attributed to him by plaintiffs’ complaints fall squarely within the protections furnished by that provision. Plaintiffs allege Powelson ordered that no actions leading to Poddar’s detention be taken. This conduct reflected Powelson’s determination not to seek Poddar’s confinement and thus falls within the statutory immunity.
Section 856 also insulates Dr. Moore for his conduct respecting confinement, although the analysis in his case is a bit more subtle. Clearly, Moore’s decision that Poddar be confined was not a proximate cause of Tatiana’s death, for indeed if Moore’s efforts to bring about Poddar’s confinement had been successful, Tatiana might still be alive today. Rather, any confinement claim against Moore must rest upon Moore’s failure to overcome Powelson’s decision and actions opposing confinement.
Such a claim, based as it necessarily would be, upon a subordinate’s failure to prevail over his superior, obviously would derive from a rather onerous duty. Whether to impose such a duty we need not decide, however, since we can confine our analysis to the question whether Moore’s failure to overcome Powelson’s decision realistically falls within the protection afforded by section 856. Based upon the allegations before us, we conclude that Moore’s conduct is protected.
Plaintiffs’ complaints imply that Moore acquiesced in Powelson’s countermand of Moore’s confinement recommendation. Such acquies
5. Defendant police officers are immune from liability for failing to
confine Poddar in their custody.
Confronting, finally, the question whether the defendant police officers are immune from liability for releasing Poddar after his brief confinement, we conclude that they are. The source of their immunity is section 5154 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, which declares that: “[t]he professional person in charge of the facility providing 72-hour treatment and evaluation, his designee, and the peace officer responsible for the detainment of the person shall not be held civilly or criminally liable for any action by a person released at or before the end of 72 hours . . . .” (Italics added.)
Although defendant police officers technically were not “peace officers” as contempláted by the Welfare and Institutions Code,
6. Plaintiffs’ complaints state no cause of action for exemplary damages.
Plaintiff’s third cause of action seeks punitive damages against defendant Powelson. The California statutes and decisions, however, have been interpreted to bar the recoveiy of punitive damages in a wrongful death action. (See Pease v. Beech Aircraft Corp. (1974) 38 Cal.App.3d 450, 460-462 [113 Cal.Rptr. 416] and authorities there cited.)
7. Conclusion
For the reasons stated, we conclude that plaintiffs can amend their complaints to state a cause of action against defendant therapists by asserting that the therapists in fact determined that Poddar presented a serious danger of violence to Tatiana, or pursuant to the standards of their profession should have so determined, but nevertheless failed to exercise reasonable care to protect her from that danger. To the extent, however, that plaintiffs base their claim that defendant therapists breached that duty because they failed to procure Poddar’s confinement, the therapists find immunity in Government Code section 856. Further, as to the police defendants we conclude that plaintiffs have failed to show that the trial court erred in sustaining their demurrer without leave to amend.
The judgment of the superior court in favor of defendants Atkinson, Beall, Brownrigg, Hallernan, and Teel is affirmed. The judgment of the superior court in favor of defendants Gold, Moore, Powelson, Yandell, and the Regents of the University of California is reversed, and the cause remanded for further proceedings consistent with the views expressed herein.
Wright, C. J., Sullivan, J., and Richardson, J., concurred.
The criminal prosecution stemming from this crime is reported in People v. Poddar (1974) 10 Cal.3d 750 [111 Cal.Rptr. 910, 518 P.2d 342],
The therapist defendants include Dr. Moore, the psychologist who examined Poddar and decided that Poddar should be committed; Dr. Gold and Dr. Yandell, psychiatrists at Cowell Memorial Hospital who concurred in Moore’s decision; and Dr. Powelson, chief of the department of psychiatry, who countermanded Moore’s decision and directed that the staff take no action to confine Poddar. The police defendants include Officers Atkinson, Brownrigg and Hallerán, who detained Poddar briefly but released him; Chief Beall, who received Moore’s letter recommending that Poddar be confined; and Officer Teel, who, along with Officer Atkinson, received Moore’s oral communication requesting detention of Poddar.
Plaintiffs’ complaints allege merely that defendant therapists failed to warn plaintiffs —Tatiana’s parents—of the danger to Tatiana. The complaints do not allege that defendant therapists failed to warn Tatiana herself, or failed to warn persons other than her parents who would be likely to apprise Tatiana of the danger. Such omissions can properly be cured by amendment. As we stated in Minsky v. City of Los Angeles (1974) 11 Cal.3d 113, 118-119 [113 Cal.Rptr. 102, 520 P.2d 726]: “It is axiomatic that if there is a reasonable possibility that a defect in the complaint can be cured by amendment or that the pleading liberally construed can state a cause of action, a demurrer should not be sustained without leave to amend.” (Accord, La Sala v. American Sav. & Loan Assn. (1971) 5 Cal.3d 864, 876 [97 Cal.Rptr. 849, 489 P.2d 1113]; Lemoge Electric v. County of San Mateo (1956) 46 Cal.2d 659, 664 [297 P.2d 638]; Beckstead v. Superior Court (1971) 21 Cal.App.3d 780, 782 [98 Cal.Rptr. 779].)
See Merrill v. Buck (1962) 58 Cal.2d 552, 562 [25 Cal.Rptr. 456, 375 P.2d 304]; Biakanja v. Irving (1958) 49 Cal.2d 647, 650 [320 P.2d 16, 65 A.L.R.2d 1358]; Walnut Creek Aggregates Co. v. Testing Engineers Inc. (1967) 248 Cal.App.2d 690, 695 [56 Cal.Rptr. 700],
This rule derives from the common law’s distinction between misfeasance and nonfeasance, and its reluctance to impose liability for the latter. (See Harper & Kime, The Duty to Control the Conduct of Another (1934) 43 Yale L.J. 886, 887.) Morally questionable, the rule owes its survival to “the difficulties of setting any standards of unselfish service to fellow men, and of making any workable rule to cover possible situations where fifty people might fail to rescue ....’’ (Prosser, Torts (4th.ed. 1971) § 56, p. 341.) Because of these practical difficulties, the courts have increased the number of instances in which affirmative duties are imposed not by direct rejection of the common law rule, but by expanding the list of special relationships which will justify departure from that rule. (See Prosser, supra, § 56, at pp. 348-350.)
The pleadings establish the requisite relationship between Poddar and both Dr. Moore, the therapist who treated Poddar, and Dr. Powelson, who supervised that treatment. Plaintiffs also allege that Dr. Gold personally examined Ppddar, and that Dr. Yandell, as Powelson’s assistant, approved the decision to arrange Poddar’s commitment. These allegations are sufficient to raise the issue whether a doctor-patient or therapist-patient relationship, giving rise to a possible duty by the doctor or therapist to exercise reasonable care to protect a threatened person of danger arising from the patient’s mental illness, existed between Gold or Yandell and Poddar. (See Harney, Medical Malpractice (1973) p. 7.)
When a “hospital has notice or knowledge of facts from which it might reasonably be concluded that a patient would be likely to harm himself or others unless preclusive measures were taken, then the hospital must use reasonable care in the circumstances to prevent such harm.” (Vistica v. Presbyterian Hospital (1967) 67 Cal.2d 465, 469 [62 Cal.Rptr. 577, 432 P.2d 193].) (Italics added.) A mental hospital may be liable if it negligently permits the escape or release of a dangerous patient (Semler v. Psychiatric Institute of Washington, D.C. (4th Cir. 1976) 44 U.S.L. Week 2439; Underwood v. United States (5th Cir. 1966) 356 F.2d 92; Fair v. United States (5th Cir. 1956) 234 F.2d 288). Greenberg v. Barbour (E.D.Pa. 1971) 322 F.Supp. 745, upheld a cause of action against a hospital staff doctor whose negligent failure to admit a mental patient resulted in that patient assaulting the plaintiff.
Kaiser v. Suburban Transportation System (1965) 65 Wn.2d 461 [398 P.2d 14]; see Freese v. Lemmon (Iowa 1973) 210 N.W.2d 576 (concurring opn. of Uhlenhopp, J.).
Ellis v. D’Angelo (1953) 116 Cal.App.2d 310 [253 P.2d 675], upheld a cause of action against parents who failed to warn a babysitter of the violent proclivities of their child; Johnson v. State of California (1968) 69 Cal.2d 782 [73 Cal.Rptr. 240, 447 P.2d 352], upheld a suit against the state for failure to warn foster parents of the dangerous tendencies of their ward; Morgan v. County of Yuba (1964) 230 Cal.App.2d 938 [41 Cal.Rptr. 508], sustained a cause of action against a sheriff who had promised to warn decedent before releasing a dangerous prisoner, but failed to do so.
See, e.g., People v. Burnick (1975) 14 Cal.3d 306, 325-328 [121 Cal.Rptr. 488, 535 P.2d 352]; Monahan, The Prevention of Violence, in Community Mental Health in the Criminal Justice System (Monahan ed. 1975); Diamond, The Psychiatric Prediction of Dangerousness (1975) 123 U.Pa.L.Rev. 439; Ennis & Litwack, Psychiatry and the Presumption of Expertise: Flipping Coins in the Courtroom (1974) 62 Cal.L.Rev. 693.
Defendant therapists and amicus also argue that warnings must be given only in those cases in which the therapist knows the identity of the victim. We recognize that in some cases it would be unreasonable to require the therapist to interrogate his patient to discover the victim’s identity, or to conduct an independent investigation. But there may also be cases in which a moment’s reflection will reveal the victim’s identity. The matter thus is one which depends upon the circumstances of each case, and should not be governed by any hard and fast rule.
Counsel for defendant Regents and amicus American Psychiatric Association predict that a decision of this court holding that a therapist may bear a duty to warn a potential victim will deter violence-prone persons from seeking therapy, and hamper the treatment of other patients. This contention was examined in Fleming and Maximov, The Patient or His Victim: The Therapist’s Dilemma (1974) 62 Cal.L.Rev. 1025, 1038-1044; they conclude that such predictions are entirely speculative. In In re Lifschutz, supra, 2 Cal.3d 415, counsel for the psychiatrist argued that if the state could compel disclosure of some psychotherapeutic communications, psychotherapy could no longer be practiced successfully. (2 Cal.3d at p. 426.) We rejected that argument, and it does not appear that our decision in fact adversely affected the practice of psychotherapy in California. Counsels’ forecast of harm in the present case, strikes us as equally dubious.
We note, moreover, that Evidence Code section 1024, enacted in 1965, established that psychotherapeutic communication is not privileged when disclosure is necessary to prevent threatened danger. We cannot accept without question counsels’ implicit assumption that effective therapy for potentially violent patients depends upon either the patient’s lack of awareness that a therapist can disclose confidential communications to avert impending danger, or upon the therapist’s advance promise never to reveal nonprivileged threats of violence.
Fleming and Maximov note that “While [section 1024] supports the therapist’s less controversial right to make a disclosure, it admittedly does not impose on him a duty to do so. But the argument does not have to be pressed that far. For if it is once conceded ... that a duty in favor of the patient’s foreseeable victims would accord with general principles of tort liability, we need no longer look to the statute for a source of duty. It is sufficient if the statute can be relied upon ... for the purpose of countering the claim that the needs of confidentiality are paramount and must therefore defeat any such hypothetical duty. In this more modest perspective, the Evidence Code’s ‘dangerous patient’ exception may be invoked with some confidence as a clear expression of legislative policy concerning the balance between the confidentiality values of the patient and the safety values of his foreseeable victims.” (Italics in original.) Fleming & Maximov, The Patient or His Victim: The Therapist's Dilemma (1974) 62 Cal.L.Rev. 1025, 1063.
Amicus suggests that a therapist who concludes that his patient is dangerous should not warn the potential victim, but institute proceedings for involuntary detention of the patient. The giving of a warning, however, would in many cases represent a far lesser inroad upon the patient’s privacy than would involuntary commitment.
See also Summary Report of the Task Force on Confidentiality of the Council on Professions and Associations of the American Psychiatric Association (1975).
Moore argues that after Powelson countermanded the decision to seek commitment for Poddar, Moore was obliged to obey the decision of his superior and that therefore he should not be held liable for any dereliction arising from his obedience to superior orders. Plaintiffs in response contend that Moore’s duty to members of the public endangered by Poddar should take precedence over his duty to obey Powelson. Since plaintiffs’ complaints do not set out the date of Powelson’s order, the specific terms of that order, or Powelson’s authority to overrule Moore’s decisions respecting patients under Moore’s care, we need not adjudicate this conflict; we pass only upon the pleadings at this stage and decide if the complaints can be amended to state a cause of action.
Division 5 includes the Lanterman-Petris-Short Act and the Short-Doyle Act (community mental health services). Division 6 relates to programs for treatment of persons judicially committed as mentally disordered sex offenders or mentally retarded. Division 7 encompasses treatment at state and county mental hospitals, the Langley Porter Neuropsychiatric Institute and the Neuropsychiatric Institute of the U.C.L.A. Medical Center.
We have considered sua sponte whether plaintiffs’ complaints could be amended to assert a cause of action against the police defendants under the principles of Restatement Second of Torts (1965) section 321, which provides that “If the actor does an act, and subsequently realizes or should realize that it has created an unreasonable risk of causing physical harm to another, he is under a duty to exercise reasonable care to prevent the risk from taking effect.” (See Hartzler v. City of San Jose, supra, 46 Cal.App.3d 6, 10.) The record, however, suggests no facts which, if inserted into the complaints, might form the foundation for such cause of action. The assertion of a cause of action against the police defendants under this theory would raise difficult problems of causation and of public policy, which should not be resolved on the basis of conjectural facts not averred in the pleadings or in any proposed amendment to those pleadings.
No more specific immunity provision of the Government Code appears to address the issue.
Section 815.2 of the Government Code declares that “[a] public entity is liable for injury proximately caused by an act or omission of an employee of the public entity within the scope of his employment if the act or omission would, apart from this section, have given rise to a cause of action against that employee or his personal representative.” The section further provides, with exceptions not applicable here, that “a public entity is not liable for an injury resulting from an act or omission of an employee of the public entity where the employee is immune from liability.” The Regents, therefore, are immune from liability only if all individual defendants are similarly immune.
We dismissed, in Johnson, the view that immunity continues to be necessary in order to insure that public employees will be sufficiently zealous in the performance of their official duties. The California Tort Claims Act of 1963 provides for indemnification of public employees against liability, absent bad faith, and also permits such employees to insist that their defenses be conducted at public expense. (See Gov. Code, §§ 825-825.6, 995-995.2.) Public employees thus no longer have a significant reason to fear liability as they go about their official tasks. We also, in Johnson, rejected the argument that a public employee’s concern over the potential liability of his or her employer serves as a basis for immunity. (Johnson v. State of California, supra, at pp. 790-793.)
By analogy, section 830.8 of the Government Code furnishes additional support for our conclusion that a failure to warn does not fall within the zone of immunity created by section 820.2. Section 830.8 provides: “Neither a public entity nor a public employee is liable ... for an injury caused by the failure to provide traffic or warning signals, signs, markings or devices described in the Vehicle Code. Nothing in this section exonerates a public entity or public employee from liability for injury proximately caused by such failure if a signal, sign, marking or device . . . was necessary to warn of a dangerous condition which endangered the safe movement of traffic and which would not be reasonably apparent to, and would not have been anticipated by, a person exercising due care.” The Legislature thus concluded at least in another context that the failure to warn of a latent danger is not an immunized discretionary omission. (See Hilts v. County of Solano (1968) 265 Cal.App.2d 161, 174 [71 Cal.Rptr. 275].)
Section 856 includes the exception to the general rule of immunity “for injury proximately caused by . . . negligent or wrongful acts or omission in carrying out or failing to carry out... a determination to confine or not to confine a person for mental illness____”
Because Dr. Gold and Dr. Yandell were Dr. Powelson’s subordinates, the analysis respecting whether they are immune for having failed to obtain Poddar’s confinement is similar to the analysis applicable to Dr. Moore.
Welfare and Institutions Code section 5008, subdivision (i), defines “peace officer” for purposes of the Lanterman-Petris-Short Act as a person specified in sections 830.1 and 830.2 of the Penal Code. Campus police do not fall within the coverage of section 830.1 and were not included in section 830.2 until 1971.