BARNES, Judge.
Belden, Inc., and Belden Wire & Cable Company (collectively "Belden") appeal the trial court's granting of partial summary judgment in favor of American Electronic Components, Inc. ("AEC"). We affirm.
Belden raises four issues, which we consolidate and restate as:
Belden manufactures wire, and AEC manufactures automobile sensors. Since 1989, AEC, in repeated transactions, has purchased wire from Belden to use in its sensors.
In 1996 and 1997, Belden sought to comply with AEC's quality control program and provided detailed information to AEC regarding the materials it used to manufacture its wire. In its assurances, Belden indicated that it would use insulation from Quantum Chemical Corp. ("Quantum"). In June 2003, however, Belden began using insulation supplied by Dow Chemical Company ("Dow"). The Dow insulation had different physical properties than the insulation provided by Quantum.
In October 2003, Belden sold AEC wire manufactured with the Dow insulation. AEC used this wire to make its sensors, and the insulation ultimately cracked. Chrysler had installed AEC's sensors containing the faulty wire in approximately 18,000 vehicles. Chrysler recalled 14,000 vehicles and repaired the remaining 4,000 prior to sale. Pursuant to an agreement with Chrysler, AEC is required to reimburse Chrysler for expenses associated with the recall.
In 2004, AEC filed a complaint against Belden seeking consequential damages for the changes in the insulation that resulted in the recall. In 2005, AEC filed a partial motion for summary judgment. In 2006, Belden responded and filed a cross-motion for summary judgment. The motions for summary judgment were "limited to the issues of duty and limitation of remedy and [did] not present any issues as to breach, causation, or damages." Appellant's App. p. 14. On July 6, 2006, the trial court held a hearing on the parties' motions for partial summary judgment. On July 6, 2007, the trial court entered an order granting AEC's motion for partial summary judgment and denying Belden's cross-motion. Belden now appeals.
In reviewing a trial court's decision to grant or deny summary judgment, we apply the same standard as the trial court. Keaton & Keaton v. Keaton,842 N.E.2d 816, 819 (Ind.2006). We decide whether there are genuine issues of material fact and whether the moving party is entitled to judgment as a matter of law. Id. Our review is limited to those materials designated to the trial court. Sees v. Bank One, Indiana, N.A.,839 N.E.2d 154, 160 (Ind. 2005) (citing Ind. Trial Rule 56(H)). We accept as true those facts alleged by the non-moving party, construe the evidence in favor of the non-moving party, and resolve all doubts against the moving party. Id. When considering cross-motions for summary judgment, the trial court is required to consider each motion separately, construing the facts most favorably to the non-moving party in each instance. Id. "We will affirm a grant of summary judgment if it can be sustained on any theory or basis in the record." Cincinnati Ins. Co. v. American Alternative Ins. Corp.,866 N.E.2d 326, 329 (Ind.Ct.App.2007), trans. denied.
Belden first argues that the boilerplate language on the back of its "customer order acknowledgement" limited the damages available to AEC. Appellant's App. p. 94. The parties were involved in repeated transactions over many years. Prior to 1998, AEC sent all purchase orders by mail on a form that contained AEC's terms and conditions on the back. Beginning in 1998, AEC sent its purchase orders to Belden via fax. The faxed purchase orders only included the front of the form and omitted the terms and conditions printed on the back of the form.
On October 17, 2003, AEC sent Belden a purchase order containing the quantity, price, shipment date, and product specifications. Belden responded on October 22, 2003, with its order acknowledgement. The order acknowledgment referenced AEC's specific requests and contained boilerplate language on the back. At issue here is the language purporting to limit Belden's liability for special, indirect, incidental, or consequential damages. See id. at 95. The back of order acknowledgment also stated:
Id. Based on these exchanges, the parties dispute whether the limitation on damages is a term of their agreement.2
We start our analysis with Section 2-207 of the Uniform Commercial Code ("UCC"),3 which provides:
The parties disagree as to whether Section 2-207(2) or Section 2-207(3) applies. In Uniroyal, Inc., v. Chambers Gasket and Manufacturing Co., 177 Ind.App. 508, 380 N.E.2d 571 (1978), we addressed a strikingly similar issue. In that case, Chambers mailed a purchase order for gaskets to Uniroyal, specifying the quantity, price, and date for shipment. Uniroyal responded with and "Order Acknowledgment" stating in part, "Our Acceptance of the order is conditional on the Buyer's acceptance of the conditions of sale printed on the reverse side hereof. If buyer does not accept these conditions of sale, he shall notify seller in writing within seven (7) days after receipt of this acknowledgment." Uniroyal, 177 Ind.App. at 508, 380 N.E.2d at 573. Included in the conditions of sale was a limitation on damages. The gaskets were later determined to be defective, Chambers sought indemnification from Uniroyal, and the trial court entered summary judgment in favor of Chambers.
On appeal, we discussed the common law rules of contract formation and the UCC's modification of those rules:
Id. at 512, 380 N.E.2d at 575 (quotations and citations omitted).
Pursuant to Section 2-207, if a contract is formed under Section 2-207(1), the additional terms in the acceptance are considered proposals and become part of the contract unless Section 2-207(2) renders the proposed terms inoperative. "However, if an acceptance is expressly conditioned on the offeror's assent to the new terms, and no assent is forthcoming, the `entire transaction aborts.'" Id. at 513, 380 N.E.2d at 575 (quoting Dorton v. Collins & Aikman Corp.,453 F.2d 1161, 1166 (6th Cir.1972)). In other words, if an acceptance contains a clause conditioning the acceptance on assent to the additional or different terms, the writings do not form a contract. Id., 380 N.E.2d at 575. "Yet if the parties' conduct recognizes the existence of a contract by performance it is sufficient to establish a contract for sale." Id., 380 N.E.2d at 575. The terms of such a contract are those on which the writings of the parties agree, "together with any supplementary terms incorporated under any other provisions of this act." § 2-207(3); see also Uniroyal, 177 Ind.App. at 513, 380 N.E.2d at 575.
We applied this framework in Uniroyal and rejected a line of cases suggesting Uniroyal's order acknowledgement was a counter-offer that Chambers accepted by taking the delivery of the goods and failing to object to the new terms. Uniroyal, 177 Ind.App. at 516-18, 380 N.E.2d at 577-78. We reasoned that such an application revives the "last-shot" doctrine under the common law "mirror-image" rule, the very rule that Section 2-207 was intended to avoid, by binding the offeror to additional terms upon the mere acceptance of goods. Id. at 517, 380 N.E.2d at 578. Further, we observed that the purpose of Section 2-207 would not be well-served by allowing an offeree's responsive document to state additional or different terms, and provide that the terms will be deemed accepted by the offeror's inaction, because Section 2-207 presumes that business people do not read exchanged preprinted forms and assumes that the offeror would not learn of such terms. Id., 380 N.E.2d at 578. We also reasoned:
Id. 517-18, 380 N.E.2d at 578 (quotation and citation omitted).
We concluded that the writings exchanged by Chambers and Uniroyal did not create a contract but that the parties performed their contractual obligations so as to create a contract under Section 2-207(3). Id. at 518, 380 N.E.2d at 578; see also Continental Grain Co., v. Followell,475 N.E.2d 318, 324 (Ind.Ct.App.1985), trans. denied, (applying Section 2-207 and Uniroyal to conclude that no contract was formed by the parties' writings or actions). Therefore, the terms of the contract consisted of the terms upon which the parties' writings agreed and the supplementary terms of the UCC. Uniroyal, 177 Ind.App. at 518, 380 N.E.2d at 578; see also § 2-207(3).
As in Uniroyal, we agree here that Belden could not unilaterally include terms that were expressly conditional on AEC's assent. Thus, the parties' writings did not create a contract. Nevertheless, we conclude that the parties' actions were in recognition of the existence of a contract and were sufficient to establish a contract for the sale of wire. The terms of the contract are the written terms on which the parties agreed and the "supplementary terms incorporated under any other provisions of [the UCC]." § 2-207(3).
The parties dispute, however, what supplementary terms are incorporated into their contract. The first question we must address is Belden's argument that the terms called for in Section 2-207(2) are included in the parties contract based on Comment 6, which provides:
§ 2-207 cmt. 6 (emphasis added).
Belden urges that, based on the emphasized language, we look to Section 2-207(2) to determine whether the terms in the order acknowledgement are included in the contract. Pursuant to Section 2-207(2), Belden contends that its additional terms became part of the contract unless they materially altered the contract — the only exclusionary provision of Section 2-207(2) that is relevant under these facts. Belden claims that the limitation on damages does not materially alter the contract.4
We need not determine whether the limitation on damages is a material alteration because we believe that Belden's reading of Comment 6 is overbroad. As the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts has observed, Comment 6 only applies where the terms conflict. Commerce & Industry Ins. Co. v. Bayer Corp.,433 Mass. 388, 742 N.E.2d 567, 573 (2001). Because only Belden's order acknowledgment contained a limitation on damages, there are no conflicting terms to implicate Comment 6. See id. Further:
Id. at 573-74; see also Coastal & Native Plant Specialties, Inc. v. Engineered Textile Prod., Inc.,139 F.Supp.2d 1326, 1337 (N.D.Fla.2001) ("[A] party cannot utilize section 2-207(2) to provide additional terms once a contract is formed pursuant to section 2-207(3).").
We agree with this reasoning. If we turned to Section 2-207(2) to determine the terms where the parties' writings did not create a contract, then Section 2-207(3) would be rendered meaningless. We will not do this. See City of Carmel v. Steele,865 N.E.2d 612, 618 (Ind.2007) ("To effectuate legislative intent, we read the sections of an act together in order that no part is rendered meaningless if it can be harmonized with the remainder of the statute."). Thus, we rely solely on Section 2-207(3) to determine what terms are included in the contract.
Belden also argues that the parties' course of dealing is a "supplementary term" to be included by Section 2-207(3). Belden contends that the parties' course of dealing acknowledges the limitation on damages and that it is therefore included as a term of the contract.
There is a split in authorities as to whether Section 2-207(3)'s reference to "supplementary terms" includes course of performance, course of dealing, and usage of trade as defined in Section 1-205 or just the standard "gap fillers" contained in the Article 2 of the UCC. Compare Coastal & Native Plant Specialties, 139 F.Supp.2d at 1337 ("When a contract is formed pursuant to section 2-207(3), as here, the contract terms consist of the standard gap-filler provisions of the UCC as well as those sections relating to course of performance and course of dealing and usage of trade."), and Dresser Industries, Inc., Waukesha Engine Div. v. Gradall Co.,965 F.2d 1442, 1451 (7th Cir.1992) (concluding that under the Wisconsin UCC, a court is not limited to the standardized gap-fillers of Article 2, but may utilize any terms arising under the entire UCC, including course of performance, course of dealing, and usage of trade), with C. Itoh & Co. (America) Inc. v. Jordan Int'l Co.,552 F.2d 1228, 1237 (7th Cir.1977) ("Accordingly, we find that the `supplementary terms' contemplated by Section 2-207(3) are limited to those supplied by the standardized `gap-filler' provisions of Article Two."). For the sake of argument, we assume, without deciding, that the parties' course of dealing is in fact a supplementary term for purposes of Section 2-207(3).
Belden asserts that during the more than 100 transactions between the parties from 1998 to 2003, AEC never objected to the limitation on damages and, therefore, the parties' course of dealing incorporates the limitation on damages into the contract.5 AEC responds, "since it is undisputed that AEC never gave its express assent to Belden's terms in any prior transaction throughout the parties' fifteen-year relationship, Belden has not established a course of dealing between the parties as a matter of law." Appellee's Br. p. 27.
Pursuant to Section 1-205(1), "A course of dealing is a sequence of previous conduct between the parties to a particular transaction which is fairly to be regarded as establishing a common basis of understanding for interpreting their expressions and other conduct." Our research shows that most cases involving the repeated exchange of forms does not in and of itself establish a course of dealing between the parties that incorporates the terms of those forms into the parties' contract under Section 2-207(3). See Step-Saver Data Sys., Inc. v. Wyse Tech.,939 F.2d 91, 103-04 (3rd Cir.1991) ("While one court has concluded that terms repeated in a number of written confirmations eventually become part of the contract even though neither party ever takes any action with respect to the issue addressed by those terms, most courts have rejected such reasoning." (footnote omitted)); see also PCS Nitrogen Fertilizer, L.P. v. Christy Refractories, L.L.C.,225 F.3d 974, 982 (8th Cir.2000) ("Moreover, the fact that Christy repeatedly sent its customer acknowledgment form to PCS does not establish a course of dealing; the multiple forms merely demonstrated Christy's desire to include the arbitration clause as a term of the contract.").
We agree with the reasoning set forth in Step-Saver:
Step-Saver, 939 F.2d at 104 (footnote omitted). Belden's repeated sending of the order acknowledgement containing the same limitation on damages and same requirement of assent by AEC does not in and of itself establish a course of dealing between the parties showing that the parties agreed to the Belden's terms and conditions of sale. At best, it shows that Belden wanted AEC to assent to its terms and conditions, which AEC never did.
Belden also asserts that AEC's acceptance of a credit or refund in other instances of alleged non-conformity establishes the parties' course of dealing regarding damages. In other words, Belden argues that by foregoing consequential damages in the past, the parties have established a course of dealing in which AEC is precluded from seeking consequential damages for this alleged breach.
A course of dealing is limited to "previous conduct between the parties." § 1-205(1). Thus, the parties' conduct after the October 2003 transaction is not relevant to establish their course of dealing for purposes of the October 2003 transaction. With this in mind, we refer to the five "material return notices" from AEC to Belden cited by Belden. These forms state the material being rejected, the reason for rejection, and AEC's request for a credit. Appellant's App. pp. 67-75.
These forms do not expressly establish that AEC has forfeited its right to seek additional damages. They simply show that AEC requested a credit for non-conforming wire. Further, that AEC did not previously claim lost profits or consequential damages does not conclusively show that AEC agreed to forego such remedies in the future. Belden has not established a course of dealing in which AEC agreed to Belden's limitation on remedies as a matter of law.
In sum, we agree with the trial court's conclusion that Section 2-207(3) applies to this case and that Section 2-207(3), not Section 2-207(2), controls the terms of the parties' agreement. We also conclude that Section 1-205 does not establish a course of dealing in which AEC agreed to the limitation on damages. The trial court properly granted summary judgment in favor of AEC as to the issue of the applicability of Belden's limitation on damages.
Belden also argues that the trial court erroneously concluded that Belden created an express warranty regarding compliance with its quality control program.6 "Where an agreement is entirely in writing, the question of whether express warranties were made is one for the court." Martin Rispens & Son v. Hall Farms, Inc.,621 N.E.2d 1078, 1082 (Ind. 1993), abrogated in part on other grounds by Hyundai Motor America, Inc., v. Goodin,822 N.E.2d 947 (Ind.2005). More specifically, if all of the representations upon which the parties rely were in writing, the existence of express warranties is a question of law. See id. Because the alleged warranty is based on written exchanges, whether the writings are sufficient to create an express warranty is a question of law appropriate for summary judgment.
In 1994, AEC indicated to its suppliers that it was adopting a quality control program to satisfy the requirements of AEC's purchasers, automobile manufacturers. AEC held a "supplier day" meeting explaining its quality control program. Two Belden representatives attended the meeting. AEC explained what its suppliers needed to do to become certified by AEC and that a certified supplier's product receives "`ship-to-stock' status, bypassing inspection, supplier is then placed on an approved supplier list." Appellee's App. p. 120. Part of AEC's quality control program included an extensive production part approval process ("PPAP"). Id. at 122.
In 1996, in an attempt to comply with AEC's quality control program, Belden completed a survey by AEC and provided detailed information regarding its ISO 9000 certification, an international accreditation, including the date of issuance, the number, the reference standard, the accreditation body stamp, and the scope of the registration. In 1997, Belden sent a letter to AEC stating in part:
Appellant's App. p. 97 (emphasis added). Among other things, the attached documents indicated that Belden used materials supplied by Quantum.7 In 1997, AEC approved Belden's PPAP.
In addition to the 1996 and 1997 statements, in 2001, Belden issued a news release that stated, "Belden Is First UL Registered Wire and Cable Company to Receive ISO 9001:2000[.]" Appellee's App. p. 63. The news release went on to state, "ISO 9001:2000 is recognized and accepted internationally as a baseline to quality management system requirements. This International Standard specifies the requirements for the quality management system that is used to address customer satisfaction, by meeting customer expectations and applicable regulatory requirements." Id.
Belden claims that these 1996 and 1997 communications did not amount to an express warranty for purposes of the October 2003 contract. Section 2-313 of the UCC provides:
"An express warranty requires some representation, term or statement as to how the product is warranted." Martin, 621 N.E.2d at 1082. There does not seem to be a dispute that in 1996 and 1997 Belden made express warranties regarding its wire. Instead, the issue is whether the 1996 and 1997 statements by Belden regarding certification created an express warranty that extended to the October 2003 contract.
Based on the designated evidence, we believe Belden's compliance with AEC's quality control program was essential to its contracts with AEC and was intended to extend to the parties' repeated contracts. First, Comment 7 to Section 2-313 provides in part, "The precise time when words of description or affirmation are made or samples are shown is not material. The sole question is whether the language or samples or models are fairly to be regarded as part of the contract." Thus, although Belden made its initial representations in 1996 and 1997, there is no indication that those representations were limited in time, that Belden subsequently disclaimed its compliance with AEC's quality control standards, or that AEC changed those standards. As the trial court observed, "it is illogical to believe that [AEC] intended to rely in this representation for only one (1) shipment of Wire and then to understand that Belden would follow whatever quality procedures it wanted as to future shipments." Appellant's App. pp. 26-27.
Further, Comment 5 of Section 2-213 provides in part, "Past deliveries may set the description of quality, either expressly or impliedly by course of dealing. Of course, all descriptions by merchants must be read against the applicable trade usages with the general rules as to merchantability resolving any doubts." Belden claims that if the parties' course of dealing was insufficient to incorporate the limitation on damages into the parties' contract, then the course of dealing is also insufficient to establish an express warranty. We disagree. Irrespective of whether the course of dealing established that AEC assented to Belden's proposed limitation on damages, the parties' course of dealing established that Belden made an express warranty regarding its compliance with the quality control standards. The limitation on damages and the express warranty are unrelated issues — there is no correlation between the two.
A course of dealing is conduct "fairly to be regarded as establishing a common basis of understanding for interpreting their expressions and other conduct." § 1-205(1). It is undisputed that Belden's wire complied with the AEC's quality control requirements for the parties' more than 100 transactions, until October 2003, when Belden switched from Quantum insulation to the Dow insulation without informing AEC of the changes. See Appellant's Br. p. 26. Based on Belden's 1996 and 1997 assertions regarding its compliance with AEC's quality control program and Belden's repeated production of wire containing Quantum insulation, Belden expressly warranted its compliance with AEC's quality control program.
That Belden and AEC did not repeatedly or routinely "communicate" regarding Belden's continued use of Quantum insulation does not undermine the parties' course of dealing. Appellant's Br. p. 26. The very point of a course of dealing is to allow the parties' prior actions create a basis of common understanding. This is exactly what Belden's 1996 and 1997 assertions taken with its continued use of Quantum insulation did.
The fact that AEC provided technical specifications prepared by an engineer that did not include the physical qualities of the wire does not negate Belden's express warranty. AEC's October 2003 purchase order refers to YR29803; this is the type of wire referred to in Belden's 1997 letter and the materials list. Although AEC's specific needs may have varied from order to order, Belden warranted the specifications of the YR29803 wire and AEC purchased YR29803 wire, subject to the engineered specifications.
Belden points out that AEC changed its specifications with each of its orders, yet "none of these changes relate to the physical properties, tensile strength and elongation or the type of insulation compound. . . ." Appellant's Br. p. 25. This shows that AEC did not want to change any of these pre-existing requirements. This fact is bolstered by AEC's statement on its order form, "Material Certification Required." Appellant's App. p. 96. Belden does not point to any designated evidence showing that AEC no longer required that Belden's materials comply with its quality control program or that Belden informed AEC that it was no longer complying with such.
Finally, in a footnote Belden contends that an express warranty can only be created when a seller states a fact of which the buyer is ignorant and claims that because AEC was a sophisticated merchant "the proposition is at once facially implausible. . . ." Appellant's Br. p. 27 n. 30. Assuming Belden raised this issue before the trial court, we disagree with its reading of Martin. A complete reading of the language upon which Belden relies shows:
Martin, 621 N.E.2d at 1082. We do not take this language to mean that a buyer has to be unsophisticated or generally ignorant before an express warranty can be created. Instead, we believe this language means that if a seller asserts a fact about which the buyer does not have knowledge to the contrary, then the seller creates an express warranty. There is no indication that AEC knew that Belden would supply wire with physical properties other than what it asserted in its 1996 and 1997 letters. This argument is without merit, and the trial court properly granted summary judgment in favor of AEC on this issue.
Belden's limitation on damages is not a term of the parties' contract and, by complying with AEC's quality control program, Belden expressly warranted its compliance with AEC's quality control program, which included the use of Quantum insulation. The trial court properly granted AEC's partial motion for summary judgment and denied Belden's partial motion for summary judgment. We affirm.
Affirmed.